Insurance advisors who truly work for you.

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Synergy Insurance Group, we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most in business and in life.
Bryan Nafrady, CLU, ChFC

Bryan Nafrady, CLU, ChFC
Executive Vice President Commercial Lines

Direct: 574-231-6564

Nathan Spite

Nathan Spite
Account Executive/Owner

Direct: 574-231-6572

David Atkinson

David Atkinson
Account Executive/Owner

Direct: 574-231-6578

Jonathan Anderstrom, CISR

Jonathan Anderstrom, CISR
Commercial Account Manager

Service: 574-231-6566

Jessica Bender

Jessica Bender
Commercial Account Manager

574-258-5555

Anthony Cox

Anthony Cox
Church Account Executive

Office: 574-258-5555

Connie Davidhizar, CISR

Connie Davidhizar, CISR
Operations Manager

Direct: 574-231-6568

Jen Fisher, CISR, PLCS

Jen Fisher, CISR, PLCS
Personal Department Manager

Direct: 574-231-6594

Kelsea Hueni, CISR

Kelsea Hueni, CISR
Commercial Account Manager

Direct: 574-231-6504

Sarah Hunsberger

Sarah Hunsberger
Personal Account Manager

574-231-6560

Wendy Hyde, CISR, PLCS

Wendy Hyde, CISR, PLCS
Personal Account Manager

Direct: 574-231-6580

Klaus Knuth

Klaus Knuth
Vice President, Benefits Division

574-231-6516

Nate Laidig, CPIA, AFIS

Nate Laidig, CPIA, AFIS
Commercial Account Executive

Direct: 574-231-6570

Jordan Leininger

Jordan Leininger
Commercial Account Executive

574-258-5555

Jon Papp

Jon Papp
Vice President, Non-Medical Benefits Division

574-231-6514

Tim Papp

Tim Papp
Commercial Account Executive

Direct: 574-406-6230

Jessica Roush

Jessica Roush
Commercial Account Manager

Service: 574-231-6566

Cathy Shamo

Cathy Shamo
Administrative Staff Support

Direct: 574-231-6506

Beth Stembel

Beth Stembel
Church Account Manager

Office: 574-258-5555

Ashton Taner

Ashton Taner
Commercial Lines Account Manager

Service: 574-231-6566

Hillary Thompson

Hillary Thompson
Account Manager, Benefits Division

574-231-6530

Jessica White, PLCS

Jessica White, PLCS
Personal Account Manager

Direct: 574-231-6590